Learn all about the devouring mother archetype, including definition, characteristics, examples and how it relates to the Caregiver archetype.
What is the Devouring Mother Archetype?
Perhaps the best way to sum up the Devouring Mother archetype is in the words of American author and famous writer on archetypes, Caroline Myss:
“The Devouring Mother “consumes” her children psychologically and emotionally and often instills in them feelings of guilt at leaving her or becoming independent.”
Devouring Oedipal Mother & Jung
The Devouring Mother is one of the four aspects of the mother archetype identified by psychoanalyst Dr Carl Jung.
The archetype is one of a mother archetype who selfishly loves her children rather than selflessly, as would be better for them. She does so out of a sense of “protecting” them from the real world.
However, in doing so she does not realize that she is in fact permanently making them infants, ever reliant on their mother for the rest of their life and incompetent when it comes to living independently in the world.
To do this the devouring mother acts in a loving manner only when her children do what she wants. When they do not she punishes them by acting in a hateful, cruel and, at it’s most extreme, even homicidal manner.
Devouring Mother Archetype Characteristics & Traits
- The archetype of the Devouring Mother is said to come from a place inside the woman concerned which is deeply afraid of being alone and afraid, in the form of solitude, of herself.
- This feat has driven her to seek the constant society of others by serving them, in doing so ensuring that they have need of her and thus she will not be left alone.
- However, having served others in this manner for such a long time the devouring mother has become controlling and obsessive in nature, sometimes even being driven to extremes such as violence, in her need to exert this control over others.
- In having either thus preyed on her family and circle of friends or had her own children in order to secure even greater control over others, the devouring mother becomes a co-dependent.
Whilst her dependents rely greatly on her for their needs, just as she desires, she relies equally or even more so on them for her own controlling and emotional needs.
This need within her becomes like a drug, causing her to smother her children or the other focus of her attention with love. Doing so stifles their ability to grow and develop as independent, capable human beings within the world.
The devouring mother is likely to instill in the child or dependent who tries to leave her feelings of guilt, using immense powers of emotional manipulation in doing so.
Pathological Version of Motherhood
Canadian clinical psychologist and a professor of psychology at the University of Toronto Jordan Peterson calls the Devouring Mother archetype the pathological version of motherhood.
He describes in depth the dangers of such a mother to their children through their overprotective nature which means that the mother devours the children’s potential and causes them to be ‘protected out of their own competence’.
Whilst they overprotect their children in a physical sense, they also protect them from any justifiable criticism or being called out for their wrong actions by other people.
In doing so they prevent their children from being raised as respectful members of society, capable of abiding by its rules and having respect for the people with whom they share their communities.
Munchausen syndrome by proxy
The Devouring Mother archetype at it’s most extreme can be seen in action in mothers who exhibit the condition ‘Munchausen syndrome by proxy’.
Munchausen syndrome by proxy (MSBP) is a mental health problem in which a caregiver, often a mother, makes up or causes an illness or injury in a person under his or her care, such as a child, an elderly adult, or a person who has a disability.
In mothers with MSBP they may lie about their child’s symptoms, change test results to make a child appear to be ill and physically harm the child to produce symptoms. Victims are most often small children who get painful and sometimes harmful medical tests they don’t need, sometimes becoming seriously ill, injured or even dying because of the actions of the mother involved.
When a devouring mother acts in this manner it is usually because she both craves the attention which the supposed illness of the child will bring her and desires to make the child more reliant on her than they would otherwise be if they were not believed to be ill.
Devouring Mother Archetype Examples
An example of the Devouring Mother archetype in film is in the character of Rose Hovick, played by actress Rosalind Russell, in the 1962 Hollywood film ‘Gypsy’.
Rose Hovick, a willful, domineering stage mother, is determined to make her daughter June a vaudeville headliner and will stop at nothing to achieve her goal.
She forces the shy, awkward and reluctant girl, who is clearly less talented than her older sister Louise, to travel with her around the country in an attempt to get them noticed and perform bookings.
As time passes the girls become too old to perform the childlike personae Rose insists they project. June elopes and, devastated by what she considers an act of betrayal, Rose focuses her energies on Louise, despite the young woman’s obvious lack of talent.
Bookings are scarce and they end up at a burlesque house in Kansas. When one of the strippers is arrested Rose offers Louise as her replacement, with Louise only agreeing to satisfy her mother. Audiences begins to like Louise as she gains confidence.
She bills herself as Gypsy Rose Lee and blossoms, finally tiring of her mother’s constant interference.
Louise demands Rose leave her alone. Rose realises she has spent her life enslaved by a desperate need to be noticed and experiences an epiphany, leading to a reconciliation with Louise.
Further reading on the devouring mother archetype includes:
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpA9pkaIamk – Idiot Compassion and the Devouring Mother by Andrew Sweeney
- H.Lawrence and the Devouring Mother Hardcover – by Judith Ruderman
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XD6qeWSA6rA – Jordan Petersen: Analysis of the Devouring Mother Archetype